# Tithe.ly vs Givebutter: Features and Cost Comparison 2026 | Capterra > Tithe.ly vs Givebutter: Which donation management tool is right for you? Dive into our detailed comparison of their features, costs, and user experience to make your decision. Source: https://www.capterra.com/compare/154664-172048/Tithe-ly-Church-Giving-vs-Givebutter --- # Tithe.ly vs Givebutter Features and Cost Comparison Last updated March 13th, 2026 Provider data verified by our Software Research team, and reviews moderated by our Reviews Verification team.[Learn more](https://www.capterra.com/our-story/) Your comparison: Tithe.lyGivebutter2/4 selected [Tithe.ly](https://www.capterra.com/p/154664/Tithe-ly-Church-Giving/)[4.7 (693)](https://www.capterra.com/p/154664/Tithe-ly-Church-Giving/reviews/) [Givebutter](https://www.capterra.com/p/172048/Givebutter/)[4.8 (871)](https://www.capterra.com/p/172048/Givebutter/reviews/) [## Tithe.ly](https://www.capterra.com/p/154664/Tithe-ly-Church-Giving/)[4.7 (693)](https://www.capterra.com/p/154664/Tithe-ly-Church-Giving/reviews/) [## Givebutter](https://www.capterra.com/p/172048/Givebutter/)[4.8 (871)](https://www.capterra.com/p/172048/Givebutter/reviews/) Starting Price Contact vendor Starting Price Contact vendor for pricing Value-for-Money 4.7 Functionality 4.5 Ease of Use 4.5 Customer Service 4.6 Starting Price Contact vendor Starting Price Contact vendor for pricing Value-for-Money 4.8 Functionality 4.5 Ease of Use 4.7 Customer Service 4.7 Reviews Sentiment Based on [693 reviews](https://www.capterra.com/p/154664/Tithe-ly-Church-Giving/reviews/) Positive 665 Neutral 20 Negative 8 Positive 665 Neutral 20 Negative 8 Reviews Sentiment JS Based on [871 reviews](https://www.capterra.com/p/172048/Givebutter/reviews/) Positive 849 Neutral 13 Negative 9 Positive 849 Neutral 13 Negative 9 Best for (according to reviews) - **Business size**: Small businesses account for 604 reviews, representing 89% of feedback, indicating strong adoption among smaller organizations. - **Industry**: Religious institutions (68%), non-profit organization management (18%), and accounting (1%) together make up 87% of industry reviews, showing a focus on faith-based and non-profit sectors. - **Use cases**: Donation management (72%), church management (30%), and membership management (25%) are primary, highlighting support for financial and community operations. Best for (according to reviews) - **Business size**: Small businesses account for 825 reviews, representing 96% of feedback, showing widespread use among smaller organizations. - **Industry**: Non-profit organization management leads with 49% of reviews, followed by education management (8%) and fund-raising (3%), indicating strong adoption in mission-driven sectors. - **Use cases**: Fundraising (76%), nonprofit (62%), and donation management (36%) are primary uses, highlighting focus on donation and campaign management. ## Not a match? Find software alternatives tailored to your priorities. These software suggestions are similar to those you’re currently comparing. ### Greater Giving 4.4 (98) * * * Starting Price Contact vendor for pricing Free Trial Free Version * * * User rating 86% of reviewers rated it above 4 stars * * * ### Planning Center 4.7 (1,138) * * * Starting Price Contact vendor for pricing Free Trial Free Version * * * User rating 96% of reviewers rated it above 4 stars * * * ### Aplos 4.5 (184) * * * Starting Price $79.00 Flat Rate,Per Month Free Trial Free Version * * * User rating 90% of reviewers rated it above 4 stars * * * Highest Rated ### ToucanTech 4.9 (151) * * * Starting Price $8000.00 Flat Rate,Per Year Free Trial Free Version * * * User rating 99% of reviewers rated it above 4 stars * * * ## Send this comparison chart to my inbox ### Fill out the form and we'll send a list of the top-rated software based on real user reviews directly to your inbox. ## Reviewer verdict Tithe.ly Tithe.ly users find it best for comprehensive church management and donation tracking, appreciating its ease of use for both administrators and members, as well as its ability to handle online and offline giving. Reviewers highlight its integration with tools like Elvanto, responsive customer service, and cost-effective pricing, though some mention limitations with website customization and occasional glitches in donation input. Givebutter Givebutter users consider it ideal for nonprofits seeking detailed donor management, customizable fundraising campaigns, and a variety of online giving options, including widgets and QR codes. Reviewers value its free tier, user-friendly interface, and integration with event ticketing and auctions, while noting the flexibility to pass fees to donors, though some express concerns about payment processing and the tipping model. ## Connect with a Capterra advisor for a free 15-minute consultation Get a personalized software list aligned to your business needs with guidance from our expert advisors. Our team has helped 1 million+ businesses like yours find options that fit their needs. ## Features comparison Beyond cost, assessing the specific features and benefits of Tithe.ly and Givebutter within the donation management space can help ensure the best fit for your needs. A well-matched option can enhance productivity while avoiding extra spending on functionalities that won't be used. Here's an overview of the key considerations and how these choices compare. \[[1](#source-item-1)\] Key features rated by users Features selected based on 11,470 reviews from Donation Management users. about the Fit Score methodology. Fit Score methodology To calculate the Fit Score, our proprietary methodology factors in the following: - The importance level for each feature. By default, this is determined by user reviews. They can rate a feature Critical, High, Low, or Not Used. - Feedback from real users on how the product performs for each key feature, derived from verified user reviews and ratings. Please note: - To calculate the Fit Score, the number of reviews for those features and the actual rating carry the same weight. You might see that, in some cases, even though the ratings are the same, we still determine a winner because it had more reviews. - If the Fit Score is not shown for a specific product, that only means there are currently not enough relevant data points to develop a meaningful score. It does not indicate that the product should be excluded from further evaluation. Tithe.ly 89%Fit Feature ratings Donation Tracking 4.7 Donor Management 4.6 Online Giving 4.7 Payment Processing 4.6 Givebutter 90%Fit Feature ratings Donation Tracking 4.7 Donor Management 4.5 Online Giving 4.9 Payment Processing 4.7 Donation Tracking 4.7 (297) 4.7 (192) Users appreciate Tithe.ly's donation tracking for its quick queries, end-of-year tax statements, and ability to track offline giving. However, some users report issues with adding cash or check donations and glitches in the admin batch giving portal. Meanwhile, Givebutter users value its detailed analytics, campaign-specific tracking, and ease of generating reports. They also appreciate the ability to track donations by campaign and receive immediate notifications. Overall, users find Tithe.ly's donation tracking helpful for online giving, while Givebutter users value its detailed analytics and campaign-specific tracking. Donor Management 4.6 (276) 4.5 (429) Reviewers find Tithe.ly's donor management useful for tracking donor information, issuing tax statements, and integrating with other products like Elvanto. However, some users mention issues with the integration and inputting member names. Givebutter users appreciate the consolidation of donor information, ease of tracking donations, and the ability to send direct communications. They also value the detailed donor profiles and the ability to manage donor data effectively. In general, users find Tithe.ly's donor management helpful for tracking and issuing statements, while Givebutter users appreciate its detailed donor profiles and communication features. Online Giving 4.7 (330) 4.9 (170) Tithe.ly users find online giving simple and accessible, appreciating the multiple ways to give, including online, texting, and POS kiosks. They appreciate the ease of use and the ability to support the church from anywhere. However, some users mention the lack of bank account giving in certain regions. Givebutter users value the variety of online giving options, including widgets, QR codes, and integration with fundraising events. They appreciate the ease of embedding links and the ability to customize campaigns. Overall, users find Tithe.ly's online giving simple and accessible, while Givebutter users appreciate its variety of options and integration capabilities. Payment Processing 4.6 (288) 4.7 (418) Tithe.ly users appreciate the quick and automated payment processing, integration with other systems, and timely notifications. However, some users report occasional delays and issues with refunds. Givebutter users value the multiple payment options, ease of processing, and the ability to cover processing fees. They also appreciate the integration with event ticketing and the clear payout records. In summary, users find Tithe.ly's payment processing quick and automated, while Givebutter users appreciate the multiple payment options and ease of processing. ## Pricing comparison ### Starting prices Tithe.ly Contact vendor for pricing Givebutter $0.00 Flat Rate Not provided by vendor Free Trial Free Version [View pricing plans](https://www.capterra.com/p/172048/Givebutter/pricing/) ### Value-for-money analysis 4.7 (693) 4.8 (871) A dive into reviewer perceptions about the value for money of both Tithe.ly and Givebutter demonstrates that Tithe.ly reviewers consider it to offer a comprehensive suite of features at an affordable price, while Givebutter reviewers comment on its cost-effective and free options for nonprofits. Reviewers find Tithe.ly to be a cost-effective solution, especially for small organizations and churches. They appreciate the all-in-one service that includes various functionalities such as church management, online giving, and event management, all for a single, low monthly fee. Users also value the affordability and the continuous addition of new features, which they say enhances the overall value for money. As for Givebutter, reviewers appreciate its free tier and the flexibility it offers nonprofits, especially those with limited budgets. They highlight the platform's user-friendly interface and the ability to pass on fees to donors, which they say helps keep costs low for organizations. However, some users mention that the fees can add up, and the tipping model for covering costs can be off-putting for some donors. ## How does the user experience compare on Tithe.ly vs Givebutter? ### Overall rating 4.7 (693) 4.8 (871) ### User interface Tithe.ly Givebutter ### Customer service and support Tithe.ly Email/Help Desk FAQs/Forum Knowledge Base Phone Support 24/7 (Live rep) Chat Givebutter Email/Help Desk FAQs/Forum Knowledge Base Phone Support 24/7 (Live rep) Chat ## What users say about the pros and cons of Tithe.ly vs Givebutter Tithe.ly and Givebutter are two options for donation management software users to meet their business needs. Both products have been reviewed on Capterra. Check out what real users say about Tithe.ly vs Givebutter to find the best fit for you. Users appreciate Tithe.ly for its effective church management, noting its ease of use for both church members and administrators. They also value its donation management capabilities, highlighting the ability to track both online and offline donations. Additionally, reviewers commend Tithe.ly's customer service, describing it as excellent and responsive. Meanwhile, Givebutter users praise its donor management, citing features like customizable reports and multiple payment options. They also find its fundraising management tools helpful, particularly for creating campaigns and tracking goals. Furthermore, users appreciate Givebutter's auction platform for its seamless integration and intuitive use. As for the cons, Tithe.ly users mention issues with website management, noting glitches and limited customization options. At the same time, Givebutter users express concerns about payment processing, citing difficulties with transaction transfers and the mandatory tipping feature. \[[2](#source-item-2)\] Pros Tithe.ly BG Benjamin G PastorNon-Profit Organization Management, Self-employedUsed the software for: More than 2 years. “You can customize almost any premade template and it is clean cut, helping others virtually discover the space God has granted you.“ February 25, 2025 BM Brian M PastorReligious Institutions, Self-employedUsed the software for: 1-2 years. “I switched to their website because of the cost, hard to beat $19/m. However, the integration of the online giving and the website is awesome.“ October 5, 2025 Givebutter JS Jenni S Lead Project ForesterRenewables & Environment, 2 - 10 employeesUsed the software for: Less than 6 months. “Everything runs seamlessly now and managing donor payouts, transactions, ticket sales, etc is very streamlined within the Givebutter dashboard - very user friendly for our team (even our 'not tech savvy' team members are using it with ease).“ October 8, 2025 GO Grisel O Director of DevelopmentNon-Profit Organization Management, 11 - 50 employeesUsed the software for: 6-12 months. “We especially appreciate the event creation feature for making RSVP pages for our community events. Though many of these events are free for community members, we've noticed that the platform enables participants to make small contributions when submitting their RSVPs.“ February 18, 2025 Cons Tithe.ly JP Jenni P office administratorReligious Institutions, 2 - 10 employeesUsed the software for: 1-2 years. “Our only complaint is that occasionally the website seems to glitch and will not past into the body section of a news item or event the content copied from a document.“ February 10, 2025 Victoria W Volunteer donations processorReligious Institutions, 2 - 10 employeesUsed the software for: Less than 6 months. “As a donation processor, it gets clumsy if you have to change the donor's contact info sometime after their initial donation in the year.“ October 14, 2024 Givebutter KW Kathy W Marketing CoordinatorFarming, 11 - 50 employeesUsed the software for: 6-12 months. “The inability to delete accidentally created pages and there is not a clear page for newsletters, it requires users to go through an event type page and when we receive a new sign-up, it looks like a donation confirmation page.“ June 5, 2024 JS Jenni S Lead Project ForesterRenewables & Environment, 2 - 10 employeesUsed the software for: Less than 6 months. “Never seem to be able to get the best features from one system and end up settling for a system that offers 'most' key features with some downsides after taking a lot of time to compare their features & pricing. “ October 8, 2025 * * * Sources 1. Our research team identified features from vendor websites based on their analysis of what users find valuable or expect from donation management software. This list is not exhaustive. For additional features, refer to the vendor’s website. 2. Review excerpts are passages extracted from longer reviews written by verified reviewers. We obtain these excerpts by applying an algorithm that considers factors including, but not limited to, length, topic coverage, and thematic relevance. Excerpts are evaluated for positive or negative sentiment and receive a sentiment score. They represent user opinion and do not represent the views of, nor constitute, an endorsement by Capterra or its affiliates. Excerpts are not edited for clarity or grammar. * * * Need Help Deciding Between Tithe.ly and Givebutter? Talk to a Capterra advisor for free and get results within 15 minutes. Popular comparisons - [Tithe.ly vs DonorPerfect](https://www.capterra.com/compare/2698-154664/DonorPerfect-Fundraising-Software-vs-Tithe-ly-Church-Giving) - [Tithe.ly vs Zeffy](https://www.capterra.com/compare/154664-220131/Tithe-ly-Church-Giving-vs-Zeffy) - [Tithe.ly vs Bloomerang](https://www.capterra.com/compare/131207-154664/Bloomerang-vs-Tithe-ly-Church-Giving) - [Tithe.ly vs Bonterra Network for Good](https://www.capterra.com/compare/111128-154664/Bonterra-Guided-Fundraising-vs-Tithe-ly-Church-Giving) - [Tithe.ly vs Donorbox](https://www.capterra.com/compare/154664-156860/Tithe-ly-Church-Giving-vs-Donorbox) - [Givebutter vs Zeffy](https://www.capterra.com/compare/172048-220131/Givebutter-vs-Zeffy) - [Givebutter vs DonorPerfect](https://www.capterra.com/compare/2698-172048/DonorPerfect-Fundraising-Software-vs-Givebutter) - [Givebutter vs Donorbox](https://www.capterra.com/compare/156860-172048/Donorbox-vs-Givebutter) - [Givebutter vs Bonterra Network for Good](https://www.capterra.com/compare/111128-172048/Bonterra-Guided-Fundraising-vs-Givebutter) - [Givebutter vs OneCause](https://www.capterra.com/compare/145329-172048/Fundraising-Software-vs-Givebutter)