Capterra Logo
Helping businesses choose better software since 1999

IconCMO vs Tithe.ly: Which is a better fit?

Updated on October 27th, 2024
Capterra offers objective, independent research and verified user reviews. We may earn a referral fee when you visit a vendor through our links.
Summary
Key features rated by users
Features selected based on 2,625 reviews from Church Management users.
% Fit
Not enough reviews
Feature ratings
For Religious Organizations
5.0
Donation Management
5.0
Membership Management
5.0
Online Giving
--
Member Communication
--
% Fit
High performer
Feature ratings
For Religious Organizations
4.7
Donation Management
4.6
Membership Management
3.9
Online Giving
4.7
Member Communication
4.3
User satisfaction
4.5
User reviews361
Ease of use
4.1
Functionality
4.2
Value for money
4.5
Customer support
4.8
4.7
User reviews632
Ease of use
4.5
Functionality
4.5
Value for money
4.7
Customer support
4.6
Price starts from
Monthly subscription
Free version
Free trial
--
Not provided by vendor
Free version
Free trial
Best for

Icon Systems offers multiple church management software packages that will meet the needs of any religious organization - from church plants to denominational offices.

Tithely is perfect for all size churches. We're currently serving everyone from church plants to churches of 15,000+ members. Our pricing & easy-to-use software make it a right fit for all churches.

User reviews
pros & cons
1 / 4
View Reviews
1 / 4
View Reviews
Video reviews
No video reviews yet
Joe H
Pastor
5.0

Speaker 1: Hi, my name's Joe. I'm the pastor of the First Presbyterian Church in Jasper, Indiana. We've been using Tithe.ly for a few months now and everything that we've used with Tithe.ly, I would give them a five out of five. Before Tithe.ly, we used two different programs. We used Wix, which is a much more complex system to put a website together if you're not very technologically prone. And then we switched over to Faithlife, which was a good fit for us, but Faithlife unfortunately ceased operations and we had to find another fit for our website and Tithe.ly was a very good fit for that. It filled all the holes that we needed. It was a very plug-in play, but still built a very nice website and had backend features that were very helpful to us. We chose Tithe.ly first and foremost because it had the features that we needed. It has background checks built into the system so that we don't have to have a third party provider and keeps track of those things for us. It also has a built-in system to keep track of both our members and those who work on different parts of our ministry. The other part that is very nice about Tithe.ly is the built-in easy-to-use sermon loader that we don't have to mess with, we don't have to think about, and automatically builds that feed for us. And the final consideration for us was price. There are several other companies out there doing very similar things to Tithe.ly, but we felt the price point and what we needed from the system really was a perfect match for us. It was very easy to start with Tithe.ly. They give you two options to start with. You can either move your website or build your website fresh with them. We chose to pay a few hundred dollars so that they could just take our existing website and build it into their platform so that it really was a pretty seamless transition and doesn't look any different than it did the week before we had Tithe.ly. So on the outside, no one can even tell that we've switched providers and that was a very helpful service for us. We're very glad to have used it that way. I would say if you're considering Tithe.ly or one of the other options specifically catered to church websites and background that they're worth talking to, they're very glad to talk to you on the phone or on a Zoom chat and they answer all the questions that you're going to need to know. The final thing that I would say is, if you're looking for an all in one platform, they're the closest you're going to get as far as I understand, including giving website people, all of that put together into one package. It's really what made Tithe.ly a perfect fit for us.

How Capterra sources reviews
View all video reviews
User interface
2675 video thumbnail}
1 Video
154664 video thumbnail}
1 Video
2675
5 screenshots
154664
4 screenshots
Do these products fit your needs?

Prioritize real-user-identified key features according to your needs to find your best fit.

Logo Img
--%
Logo Img
--%
Accounting Integration
207
Important
Activity Dashboard
388
Important

IconCMO

Top Features
36/43
  • Activity Dashboard
  • Alerts/Notifications
  • Credit Card Processing
  • Forms Management
  • Social Media Integration
  • Website Management
  • Worship Planning
  • Accounting Integration
  • API
  • Attendance Tracking
  • Built-in Accounting
  • Child Check-in
  • Communication Management
  • Contact Database
  • Contact Management
  • Customizable Branding
  • Customizable Reports
  • Customizable Templates
  • Data Import/Export
  • Donation Management
  • Electronic Payments
  • Email Management
  • Event Management
  • Event Scheduling
  • For Religious Organizations
  • Member Communication
  • Member Directory
  • Member Portal
  • Membership Management
  • Mobile Access
  • Multi-Location
  • Online Calendar
  • Online Giving
  • Pledge Management
  • Registration Management
  • Reminders
  • Reporting & Statistics
  • Role-Based Permissions
  • Small Group Management
  • SMS Messaging
  • Third-Party Integrations
  • Visitor Tracking
  • Volunteer Management
See All features
Hide Church Management Software Features -

Tithe.ly

19/43
Show Church Management Software Features +

IconCMO

--

Tithe.ly

--

IconCMO
Deployment
  • Cloud, SaaS, Web-Based
  • Desktop - Mac
  • Desktop - Windows
  • Desktop - Linux
  • Desktop - Chromebook
  • On-Premise - Windows
  • On-Premise - Linux
  • Mobile - Android
  • Mobile - iPhone
  • Mobile - iPad
Support
  • Email/Help Desk
  • FAQs/Forum
  • Knowledge Base
  • Phone Support
  • 24/7 (Live rep)
  • Chat
Training
  • In Person
  • Live Online
  • Webinars
  • Documentation
  • Videos
Tithe.ly
Deployment
  • Cloud, SaaS, Web-Based
  • Desktop - Mac
  • Desktop - Windows
  • Desktop - Linux
  • Desktop - Chromebook
  • On-Premise - Windows
  • On-Premise - Linux
  • Mobile - Android
  • Mobile - iPhone
  • Mobile - iPad
Support
  • Email/Help Desk
  • FAQs/Forum
  • Knowledge Base
  • Phone Support
  • 24/7 (Live rep)
  • Chat
Training
  • In Person
  • Live Online
  • Webinars
  • Documentation
  • Videos
IconCMO
  • By Icon Systems
  • Located in United States
  • Founded in 1992
Tithe.ly
  • By Tithe.ly
  • Located in United States
  • Founded in 2010
Recommendations

Products similar to those you're currently comparing: