Capterra’s researchers use a mix of verified reviews, independent research and objective methodologies to bring you selection and ranking information you can trust. While we may earn a referral fee when you visit a provider through our links or speak to an advisor, this has no influence on our research or methodology.
Capterra carefully verified over 2 million reviews to bring you authentic software and services experiences from real users. Our human moderators verify that reviewers are real people and that reviews are authentic. They use leading tech to analyze text quality and to detect plagiarism and generative AI. Learn more.
Capterra lists all providers across its website—not just those that pay us—so that users can make informed purchase decisions. Capterra is free for users. Software and service providers pay us for sponsored profiles to receive web traffic and sales opportunities. Sponsored profiles include a link-out icon that takes users to the provider’s website. Learn more.
With over 4,000 customers, iCIMS' Talent Cloud is made for enterprise organizations with over 100 employees, primarily in the healthcare, financial services, manufacturing, and retail industries.
ADP Workforce Now serves clients across nearly every industry who are looking to manage their human capital management needs across HR, payroll, benefits, talent, time & labor, analytics and more.
We LOVE iCims here, have for the past 10-ish years. The product keeps developing and growing; it's pretty impressive how they strive to keep pace for small to VERY large customers.
There are some inefficiencies as you maneuver through the system and a few misleading steps.
Overall, iCIMS Talent Platform is a great way of hiring the best resources for your organization. The dashboard is user-friendly and it allows one to track all requisitions through various stages.
I can't ever seem to figure out why some hires do not populate in reports which is frustrating and can lead to missed new hires.
Ease in creating and posting open jobs and recruiting candidates are awesome through this system. Reports are excellent also as well as the customize-able dashboards.
It's very overwhelming and difficult to navigate. It's also very difficult to see where candidates are at in the process.
I like that it has all of the capabilities and integrations that are easy to setup and get working. I like the annual review of the system and the helpful advice iCIMS provides to improve the system.
Inability of workflows to work with each other. Limitations regarding employee referrals.
I use ADP on a daily basis to help administer payroll for thousands of employees. There’s a reason it’s so popular; it’s very user friendly and has a pleasant and logically put together interface.
The interface to request days off is very confusing. I ended up requesting the wrong days off or using vacation days instead of my free personal days, etc. and so that was frustrating.
The Payroll, HR and Benefits management modules are most useful and critical for our needs. Our dedicated support person is top tier and very helpful.
Being 100% unable to rely on their product support to fix our issues can be a huge problem when the error involves payroll which is under a deadline.
It is easy to use and follow, the help along the way makes it very user friendly. When I am following thru it is helpful the help button.
I am not able to find anything I dislike using this software. If there was the least dislike about this software but when the internet goes down I am unable to acess my information.
The benefits tool is also very beneficial as it is an excellent tracker for all of the benefits and benefit options given to the employees.
The application itself was not easy to understand and was also difficult to simply set up. This may have been a user error but I am fairly tech savvy - so I was disappointed overall.
Anthony: I'm Anthony, senior HR business partner. Our organization has 80,000 employees and I give iCIMS five rating. Prior to iCIMS, we had PeopleSoft as our applicant tracking system and PeopleSoft had some limitations in terms of resume search. Having iCIMS allows you to optimize your candidate search and manage candidates more quickly and appropriately, and candidates have a better candidate experience. iCIMS is a great tool. It has a great user interface both for the talent acquisition recruiter, the hiring manager, as well as prospective applicants. It allows you to engage with candidates even if you don't have an open position, which it allows you to keep your pipeline warm. iCIMS Is very easy to set up both as an initial tool for an applicant tracking system or to migrate data from your previous applicant tracking system or your HRMS system for your talent acquisition needs. It's easy to use. It is a platform that is pretty quick for hiring managers and recruiters to get used to and use effectively immediately. Anyone who decides to use iCIMS as an applicant tracking system and as a candidate management pool, I would suggest also adding on SkillSurvey. And when you have SkillSurvey coupled with iCIMS, it allows you to conduct references for prospective candidates and your time to fill will decrease in a expeditious manner. So anyone who is considering iCIMS, I would suggest having an add-on with SkillSurvey to optimize both your candidate experience as well as your time to fill.
Donald: Yes, I'm Donald. I work with Gardner-Webb University as a standardized patient, and I would rate the ADP software with the five stars out of five stars. The previous software that was being used, it wasn't as quick and easy as the ADP. It was outdated, and so people were having trouble getting everything submitted for hours, and so there was an issue with just the software not really being updated frequently that we had. So, ADP was something that was being updated frequently and was easier to use than the old software. We chose ADP Workforce software because it was something that had great reviews, it was being used by other companies, and we did some research on it to figure out that the ADP was being reviewed very well, and that it seemed to be a decent program that could provide everything we needed as far as being able to submit the times, being able to keep track of the different people that were working and that. So, it seemed to me more convenient, have great reviews, and was being used by a lot of other companies based on searches done on the ADP software. It's very easy for it to be integrated. Once it was set up, then we were able to access it very quick and easy. The information provided and the app itself was easy to fall along with and didn't take very long for everybody to get adjusted and acclimated to it. I highly recommend ADP Workforce. I think it would be great for others to use because of easy access, navigation is great. It's something that doesn't have a lot of issues like troubleshooting problems. It seems to function very well, and I've not had any issues with it. So, I definitely recommend that. I'd say the others should use it for the ease of access and the functioning of it.
Prioritize real-user-identified key features according to your needs to find your best fit.
iCIMS Talent Cloud
Top FeaturesADP Workforce Now
iCIMS Talent Cloud
ADP Workforce Now
Talk with a software expert for free. Get a list of software that’s great for you in less than 15 minutes.
Products similar to those you're currently comparing: