---
title: "Criteria Reviews 2026. Verified Reviews, Pros & Cons | Capterra"
description: "Is Criteria the right Pre-employment Testing solution for you? Explore 232 verified user reviews from people in industries like yours to make a confident choice."
source_url: "https://www.capterra.com/p/119740/Criteria/reviews/"
page_type: "reviews"
language: "en"
publication_date: "2026-11-05"
---

Criteria

4.7 (241)

Provider data verified by our Software Research team, and reviews moderated by our Reviews Verification team. [Learn more](https://www.capterra.com/our-story/)

* * *

Last updated November 5th, 2026

# Reviews of Criteria

Ease of use

4.6

Customer Service

4.7

## Pros and Cons in Reviews

BJ

Bryan J

Talent Acquisition ManagerBiotechnology, 501 - 1,000 employeesUsed the software for: 1-2 years.

“Incorporating these aptitude assessments into our hiring process has added real value by giving our managers an additional “talent signal” to consider when evaluating candidates. “

September 1, 2026

Maggie C

RecruiterMedical Devices, 1,001 - 5,000 employeesUsed the software for: Less than 6 months.

“Her "training" with us was a 15 minute screen share rather than a deep dive into the process, and she missed several emails that we sent regarding job descriptions.“

August 24, 2026

SA

Sakshi A

Talent Acquisition Operations AnalystFinancial Services, 10,001+ employeesUsed the software for: Less than 6 months.

“I particularly liked the customization options available through TestMaker, as we can create our own assessments according to our specific needs.“

September 2, 2026

Maggie C

RecruiterMedical Devices, 1,001 - 5,000 employeesUsed the software for: Less than 6 months.

“Our experience started a little rough and we ran into issues with there being too many modules selected on the CBST so the assessment was taking 40+ minutes.“

August 24, 2026

SA

Sakshi A

Talent Acquisition Operations AnalystFinancial Services, 10,001+ employeesUsed the software for: Less than 6 months.

“It offers a wide variety of assessments and a comprehensive question bank, which is useful for evaluating candidates across different roles.“

September 2, 2026

ML

Markarius L

HR GeneralistE-Learning, 501 - 1,000 employeesUsed the software for: 1-2 years.

“Some assessments can feel lengthy from a candidate's perspective, which may impact completion rates for certain applicants.“

August 31, 2026

SM

Sergio M

TA PartnerInformation Technology and Services, 1,001 - 5,000 employeesUsed the software for: 1-2 years.

“It provides reliable, data-driven insights that have improved our quality of hire and streamlined our early-stage screening.“

June 10, 2026

VK

Val K

CEO and Co-FounderInformation Technology and Services, 11 - 50 employeesUsed the software for: More than 2 years.

“Additionally, they only provide one live environment making it frustrating to test the ATS integration.“

June 29, 2026

## Showing most helpful reviews

Showing 1-25 of 241 available reviews

Sort by:

Most Helpful

Rating

Company Size

Reviewer's Role

Length of Use

Frequency of Use

Andy L.

### "Flexible Interviews, Helpful AI, Occasional Login Hiccups"

October 31, 2026

5.0

I use Criteria for interviewing and managing my time. Face-to-face interviews are hard, so I can access interviews on the cloud or video when I can and as often as I can.

Pros

I absolutely love Criteria. I can do interviews on my own time and get to them when I can, as often as I can. I thoroughly enjoy how simple it is: I can see which people I still need to interview and which interviews are done, and it’s easy to find where I’m at. I like the AI feature because it breaks things down and can provide transcriptions when I can’t listen to the audio. The summaries of what candidates said and the captions are really nice, and I can do interviews wherever I’m at. Setup was super easy—just click, click, boom, done—and everybody was loaded on there. It’s user friendly.

Cons

I sometimes find logging in frustrating because I have to reload the page. It seems to get hung up on the login tokens: it logs me in, but the page won’t load with the previous login information. Other than that, I haven’t run into any issues for what I need.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

November 2, 2026

Hi Andy, thanks so much for the kind words and for taking the time to share such detailed feedback! We're happy to hear how Criteria gives you the flexibility to complete interviews on your own schedule, from wherever you are. It's great to hear that the interview tracking, AI-generated summaries, transcriptions and captions are saving you time, and that setup was quick and painless. We're sorry about the login issue. Having to reload the page after logging in is frustrating, and we appreciate you flagging it. If you're still seeing this, please reach out to our Customer Support team so we can look into it with you directly. Details such as your browser and whether you're using a saved login can help us track it down faster. Thanks again for being a Criteria customer!

Kristina B.  
Recruiter  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "CCAT Makes Screening Candidates Fast and Effective"

October 23, 2026

4.5

It is helping us find individuals who have a high level of critical thinking and adaptability, and can work well in our environment and pace

Pros

I find the CCAT very useful in eliminating people who would struggle in our environment

Cons

I wish that the illustrate assessment allowed specific breakdowns of the competencies in an easier and accessible way

Alternatives considered

[Prevue Assessments](https://www.capterra.com/p/145622/Prevue-Assessments/)

Reasons for choosing Criteria

It looked like had the best options and more capability

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

October 23, 2026

Hi Kristina, thank you for your review! We're thrilled to hear that the CCAT has been helping you efficiently identify candidates with the critical thinking and problem-solving skills needed to succeed. It's rewarding to know that the assessment is helping your team make more informed hiring decisions and quickly focus on candidates who are most likely to thrive. We also appreciate your feedback on the Illustrate assessment results. Making competency insights easier to access and interpret is important, and suggestions like yours help us identify opportunities to improve the experience for our customers. Thank you for sharing your perspective and for trusting Criteria as part of your hiring process. We look forward to continuing to support your team's success.

RO

Robert O.

### "Collaborative Hiring Assessments That Reduce Fraud"

October 22, 2026

4.5

I use Criteria to address application and resume fraud with a test that can’t be used with AI, giving us a true read on a candidate’s characteristics and potential success at the company.

Pros

I appreciate that Criteria reaches out for our input on the product, how we use it, what needs to be done, and what’s happening in the industry. It’s great to have a partner that’s working with the changes in AI and helps my recruiters spend less time screening potentially wrong or fraudulent candidates. I also like being involved in developing programs and test assessments that help make our decisions easier and quicker. Having tests that can’t be used with AI to get a true read on a candidate’s characteristics and potential success at the company is a big help for us.

Cons

I find the integration with our ATS/CRM can be spotty, especially when we're recruiting in different locations outside the US, where the integrations aren't fully working. It can be frustrating sometimes.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

October 23, 2026

Hi Robert - thank you for your thoughtful review. We're thrilled to hear that Criteria has been a valuable partner in your hiring process. It's rewarding to know that our collaborative approach, commitment to customer feedback, and ongoing innovation around AI-related hiring challenges are helping your recruiters save time and make more confident hiring decisions. We're also glad that our assessments are helping you address concerns about resume and application fraud while providing deeper insights into candidate potential and fit. We appreciate your candid feedback regarding ATS and CRM integrations, particularly for recruiting efforts outside the U.S. We understand how important seamless integrations are to maintaining an efficient hiring workflow, and we're continually working to enhance the reliability and reach of our integration capabilities. Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and for partnering with us to help shape the future of talent assessment. We look forward to continuing to support your team's success!

Tamara M.

### "Simple to Use, with a Broader View of Student Readiness and Employee Hiring"

October 13, 2026

4.5

We use Criteria’s personality tests to see whether students are ready to take accelerated programs.

Pros

We find Criteria very simple and easy to use. It's a great program for seeing how students score on personality, using computers, and knowledge of certain activities in life as they get ready for an accelerated allied health school.

Cons

NA

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

October 14, 2026

Hi Tamara, thank you for your thoughtful review! We're delighted to hear that Criteria has been simple and easy to use while helping you gain valuable insights into student readiness for accelerated allied health programs. It's especially rewarding to know that our personality assessments are supporting your efforts to evaluate key traits and competencies as students prepare for their next steps. Our goal is to provide meaningful, actionable insights that help organizations make confident decisions, and we're glad Criteria is delivering value for your team. We appreciate your feedback and thank you for choosing Criteria as part of your student assessment process!

AH

Ashlee H.  
Talent Acquisition Manager  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Becoming obselete?"

September 16, 2026

3.0

Criteria's platform is very easy to use, which I appreciate. The product itself is good. It's just impossible to know the authenticity of candidate's results anymore.

Pros

Criteria assessments can provide some valuable insights into candidate strengths and cognitive abilities.

Cons

It's unreliable data. Candidates complete assessments with no accountability. Currently, I suspect a large number of candidates are using AI technologies to complete these tasks, making the results completely irrelevant.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 17, 2026

Hi Ashlee, thank you for your feedback and for being a Criteria customer for more than two years. We're glad you've found the platform easy to use and that our assessments have provided valuable insights. We understand concerns about candidate authenticity. Ensuring assessment integrity is a top priority, which is why we continue to invest in security measures and enhancements designed to identify unusual testing patterns and support confidence in results. For organizations seeking additional safeguards, we also recommend our assessment proctoring options. As technology evolves, so do our tools and methodologies. We remain committed to helping employers gain trustworthy insights while adapting to the changing hiring landscape. Please reach out with any additional feedback to your Customer Success Manager, and learn more about our candidate integrity measures here: https://criteriacorp.sharepoint.com/:b:/s/Collateral/IQCHxe\_GWUBXTLa6yppFUno2AV9tKtrxqs0xxkEbEsCfejQ?e=x0M7RD

Talent Acquisition Partner  
Used the software for: Less than 1 year

### "A Valuable Tool for Identifying Top Talent"

September 15, 2026

5.0

Overall, my experience with Criteria has been positive. The platform is user-friendly and provides valuable insights to support the candidate assessment process.

Pros

What I liked most about Criteria was how user-friendly and structured the platform is. It made the assessment process straightforward and provided useful insights to support the overall candidate evaluation.

Cons

Some of the assessments can be quite long, which may make it challenging for candidates to stay fully engaged throughout the process. Shortening certain assessments could make the experience more efficient while still providing valuable insights.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 17, 2026

Thank you for your review, Junior! We're happy to hear that you've had a positive experience with Criteria and that you find the platform user-friendly and helpful in supporting candidate evaluations. We also appreciate your feedback about assessment length. Creating an engaging candidate experience while delivering meaningful hiring insights is something we continuously work to balance. Your suggestion is valuable, and we're always exploring ways to optimize assessments for both efficiency and effectiveness. Thank you for choosing Criteria and for sharing your experience. We're pleased to support your hiring efforts and look forward to continuing to help your team!

Recruiting Operations Manager  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "Criteria Corp Feedback"

September 11, 2026

5.0

My overall experience has been pretty good as far as systems, customer service and the customization of the company needs. Being able to log in with SSO instead of having to reset passwords every few months has also been a game changer from a security standpoint as well. We do not have to worry about deactivating a "seat" as quickly as we would if we has personal password logins. The site is also user friendly and easy to navigate.

Pros

The Integration to ICIMS is seamless process when our hiring managers are checking candidate results. They really appreciate being able to view these skill assessments to help make a better decision when hiring candidates.

Cons

There isn't a way to export multiple candidate results at once. They must be downloaded individually

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 14, 2026

Thank you for your review, Armanii! We're glad to hear that the iCIMS integration is seamless and that hiring managers find assessment results helpful for making informed hiring decisions. It's also great to know that SSO, platform customization, customer service, and the user-friendly experience have added value for your team. We appreciate your feedback about bulk exporting candidate results and will share it with our product team. Thank you for partnering with Criteria. We're excited to continue supporting your hiring goals!

Human Resources Business Partner  
Used the software for: Less than 1 year

### "Great Testing Software "

September 7, 2026

5.0

Overall, it has been a great experience, a very friendly team and very user-friendly software. Great security features to protect our account.

Pros

The ability to create custom tests with various question types was worth the money spent. The list of skill assessments is impressive.

Cons

The duration of the Microsoft test was shorter than what we are used to. Additionally, it would be beneficial to have the option to assign more than one mark per question in the system, rather than having each question default to just one mark.

Switched from

[TestGenius](https://www.capterra.com/p/215401/TestGenius/)

Lack of custom tests with Test Genius software.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 14, 2026

Thank you for your review, Brandon. We're happy to hear that you've had a great experience with Criteria and that our custom test builder, broad range of skill assessments, and user-friendly platform have delivered value for your team. It's also wonderful to know that our team's support and the platform's security features have contributed positively to your experience. We appreciate your feedback regarding the Microsoft test duration and scoring flexibility for custom questions. Insights like yours help us better understand how customers use the platform and where additional customization could enhance the experience. Thank you for choosing Criteria and for taking the time to share your feedback. We're excited to continue supporting your hiring efforts and helping your team make confident, data-driven talent decisions.

Onboarding Coordinator  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Criteria is a very good choice!"

September 7, 2026

5.0

So far, I have not encountered any significant drawbacks, and I am satisfied with how well it supports our recruitment needs.

Pros

Overall, Criteria has been a valuable tool in supporting our hiring and onboarding processes. It helps streamline candidate evaluations while providing a convenient experience for everyone involved.

Cons

None so far. I find Criteria to be a very useful platform for candidate assessment. It makes the recruitment process more organized, efficient, and straightforward, especially when evaluating candidates consistently.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 14, 2026

Thank you for your review, Jazztene! We're so happy to hear that Criteria has been a valuable part of your hiring and onboarding processes for more than two years. It's really rewarding to know that the platform helps streamline candidate evaluations while creating a convenient and consistent experience for everyone involved. We're also grateful to hear that Criteria has helped make your recruitment process more organized, efficient, and straightforward. Consistency in candidate evaluation is so critical to making confident hiring decisions, and we're proud to support your team in this. Thank you for your continued trust in Criteria and for taking the time to share your experience.

HR  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "User-Friendly Platform"

September 7, 2026

4.0

Overall, my experience with Criteria has been good. It’s easy to use and helps keep the candidate assessment process organized. I feel like it’s secure and provides good value for the features it offers. I haven’t really used the payroll management features, so I can’t speak much about that.

Pros

I liked that Criteria was easy to use and didn’t take much time to learn. The features are straightforward, and it makes the candidate assessment process simple and organized.

Cons

The only thing I’d say is that it would be nice to have more options to customize the assessments for specific roles. More flexibility with the questions would make it easier to fit the assessment to the position.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 14, 2026

Thank you for taking the time to share your experience, Erika! We're happy that you found Criteria easy to learn and use, and that it helps keep your candidate assessment process organized and efficient. Making hiring workflows simple, secure, and effective is a key priority for us, so it's great to know we're delivering value for your team. We also appreciate your feedback about assessment customization. We're always looking for ways to give customers more flexibility while maintaining the scientific rigor and predictive validity of our assessments. Insights like yours help guide future improvements. Thank you for choosing Criteria!

Verified Reviewer

5.0

October 22, 2026

AI summary based on a full review

Using Criteria's assessments helps in filtering out unqualified candidates efficiently, saving significant time in the hiring process. Some advanced features are locked behind a paywall, which could be seen as a limitation.

Log in to unlock the full review, detailed ratings, and pros & cons

Senior Recruiter

5.0

October 22, 2026

AI summary based on a full review

Using Criteria has streamlined the candidate screening process, making it easy to identify suitable candidates based on their cognitive abilities. However, there is a potential area for improvement in addressing regional nuances that may influence assessment results.

Log in to unlock the full review, detailed ratings, and pros & cons

PX Operations Specialist

5.0

October 16, 2026

AI summary based on a full review

Using Criteria as a preliminary assessment tool helps organizations gauge candidate interest and compatibility with the company. The insights gained from the assessments, including personality traits and problem-solving abilities, enhance the pre-screening process.

Log in to unlock the full review, detailed ratings, and pros & cons

Verified Reviewer

4.0

October 14, 2026

AI summary based on a full review

The service offers a range of validated assessments and good customer support, making it a reliable choice for pre-employment testing. On the downside, the lack of flexibility in test customization can hinder its effectiveness for more complex assessments.

Log in to unlock the full review, detailed ratings, and pros & cons

Staffing Analyst

Used the software for: 1-3 years

4.5

October 13, 2026

AI summary based on a full review

The platform's design is visually appealing, and it effectively helps managers understand candidates' critical thinking abilities, which is a significant advantage. However, the instructions could be simplified for better user comprehension.

Log in to unlock the full review, detailed ratings, and pros & cons

Recruiting Manager  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "Criteria making hiring better"

July 7, 2026

5.0

The staff at Criteria has been incredibly responsive and helpful, consistently providing excellent suggestions on how we can better utilize the full range of features the platform offers.

Pros

I highly value the ability to curate assessments specifically tailored to each role. It allows for a much more precise evaluation process. Furthermore, the platform enables us to use performance scores to validate our hiring quality, providing historical data that will be invaluable for making more informed, data-driven hiring decisions in the future.

Cons

One significant drawback is the inability to view or export aggregate test scores for all candidates in one place. This forces us to manually track and compile data in external spreadsheets, which is time-consuming and prevents us from easily leveraging historical data to inform future hiring decisions.

Alternatives considered

[TestGorilla](https://www.capterra.com/p/203823/TestGorilla/)

Reasons for choosing Criteria

Appeared to be the better fit for our current needs

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

July 7, 2026

Hi Robert - thank you for taking the time to share such thoughtful and detailed feedback. We’re glad to hear that the ability to tailor assessments by role and leverage performance data is helping your team drive more precise, data-informed hiring decisions. That’s exactly the kind of impact we aim to deliver, and it’s great to see it resonating in your process. We also appreciate your candid feedback regarding aggregate reporting. Feedback like yours plays an important role in shaping our product roadmap. It’s also great to hear that our team has been a strong partner in helping you get the most out of the platform. We’ll be sure to share your kind words with them. Thank you for choosing Criteria!

Talent Acquisition Officer  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Criteria- Talent Hunt"

August 22, 2026

5.0

My overall experience remains very good with it. As I am a Talent Acquisition officer and also working on payroll as well, it is making my work easy.

Pros

Criteria Software offers a user-friendly experience with a manageable learning curve and strong security for HR data. It provides good value for money with comprehensive features, customization options, and efficient candidate interview management. Its payroll management capabilities also help automate processes, reduce manual work, and improve accuracy.

Cons

Criteria Software have advanced features, and some customizations can require additional technical support. Cost will increase with additional users or features, while certain advanced HR, interview, and payroll requirements may need extra configuration.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

August 24, 2026

Hi Muhammad, thank you for your review and for sharing your experience with Criteria! We're delighted to hear that the platform has helped make your work as a Talent Acquisition Officer and payroll professional easier and more efficient. It's rewarding to know that you value our user-friendly experience, candidate interview management tools, payroll automation capabilities, customization options, and overall value for money. We also appreciate your balanced feedback regarding advanced features. We understand that some specialized HR, interview, and payroll needs may require extra configuration or technical support, and we continuously work to improve the implementation experience while providing the guidance our customers need to achieve their goals. Thank you for choosing Criteria Software and for taking the time to share your positive experience!

Recruiter  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "Recruiter Experience and Hiring Team's Value from CCAT "

September 2, 2026

2.0

My overall experience with Criteria has been okay. I think overall the product did a great job with integration with the ATS system but to be honest I don't 100% see the value in the product itself coming from the recruiting side or the hiring team size.

Pros

I like the integration between GreenHouse. It is super easy to use and very intuitive for folks that are sending out the CCAT to candidates through our ATS system.

Cons

I don't think it provides a whole lot of information to the Hiring Manager that isn't something we can find from a normal interview process. It's been difficult getting Hiring Teams to read through the results and use the data provided and most of them feel they don't think it provides any additional information that would be necessary to make a hiring decision. I also don't like that you can't send a second criteria corp link through our GH integration and instead we have to go on Criteria Corp's website to find the candidate and send it via the web browser.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 2, 2026

Thank you for your feedback, Tiffany. We're glad to hear the Greenhouse integration has been intuitive and helps streamline the assessment process for your recruiting team. We appreciate your candid perspective on hiring team adoption and the perceived value of assessment results. Our assessments are designed to complement interviews by adding objective, science-backed insights that can help identify aptitude and potential beyond what's typically uncovered through resumes and interviews alone. We recognize that the impact is greatest when hiring teams actively engage with the results, and feedback like yours helps us continue improving the usability of those insights. Thank you again for sharing your experience with us.

TA Supervisor  
Used the software for: Less than 1 year

### "TA Supervisor "

September 2, 2026

5.0

Overall, my experience with Criteria was positive. It provided an efficient and consistent way to add another layer of data to our candidate evaluation process and was easy to manage from a recruiting perspective. I found it most valuable when the assessment results were used alongside recruiter screening, technical experience, and hiring manager feedback rather than as a standalone measure of candidate quality.

Pros

Criteria was easy to use and gave us a consistent, standardized way to assess candidates beyond what we could gather from a resume or initial screening. I especially liked the ability to use assessments such as the CCAT to better understand a candidate’s aptitude and problem-solving ability. The platform was straightforward for both recruiters and candidates, and results were easy to review and incorporate into the hiring process.

Cons

The biggest limitation was that assessment results did not always tell the full story of a candidate. For some of the highly technical and field-based positions we recruit for, relevant industry experience and hands-on knowledge can be more valuable than performance on a standardized assessment. Because of that, Criteria worked best as one data point in the hiring decision rather than a deciding factor.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 2, 2026

Hi Alexandra, thank you for sharing your experience with Criteria! We're glad to hear that the platform provided a consistent and standardized way to evaluate candidates, and that assessments like the CCAT helped uncover insights beyond resumes and initial screenings. It's great to know the experience was straightforward for both recruiters and candidates, and that the results were easy to incorporate into your hiring process. We also appreciate your perspective on the role of assessments in hiring. We agree that the best hiring decisions come from combining assessment insights with recruiter expertise, relevant experience, and hiring manager feedback. Thank you for highlighting the value of using multiple data points to build a more complete picture of each candidate, and for trusting Criteria as part of your hiring process.

Talent Performance Business Partner  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "A Lot of Potential, But Takes Work to Make It Fit Our Needs"

August 30, 2026

4.0

Overall, I would say our experience with Criteria has been mixed. There are a lot of things I like about the platform, and I think there is a lot of potential there. The Criteria team has been helpful and willing to work with us, especially as we worked through the integration issues and looked for ways to improve our process. At the same time, it took a lot of effort on our side to get the product working in a way that fit our organization. We are continuing to look for ways to get more value out of the platform, and our recent conversations around improving our assessment strategy and using video interviews to help with job alignment have been helpful. I just don't think the product has fully operated the way we originally expected it to for our organization.

Pros

Criteria has a lot of great tools and capabilities, especially around assessments. Their team has also been willing to work with us through some of the challenges we’ve had. Once we were able to get our process up and running, they helped us make our testing more effective, and we’ve been able to assess a large number of candidates. I also like that there are opportunities to use the platform beyond recruiting, such as for team and leadership development.

Cons

Our biggest challenge was the Workday integration. We were originally sold on the product working with our Workday recruiting process, but because most of our candidates come through Indeed Easy Apply, we quickly ran into integration issues. We spent a lot of time working with Criteria and another team to come up with a workaround, and because of that, we really didn't get the value we expected from the product during the first year of our contract. We have also had some challenges getting more strategic guidance. For example, when we wanted to better understand how to use the personality assessment for team and leadership development, the information we received was often similar to what we could already find and read on the platform. We were hoping for more customized recommendations and insights on how to really make the most of the tool. We've also heard from some leaders who have used other personality assessments that they don't have the same level of trust or confidence in Criteria's assessment.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 2, 2026

Thank you for your thoughtful feedback, Jordan. We're pleased to hear that you've found value in our assessment tools and that our team helped support your high-volume recruiting needs (we love our customer success team!). We appreciate your feedback regarding the Workday and Indeed Easy Apply integration challenges. We understand how important a seamless workflow is and recognize that these obstacles impacted the value you expected during your first year. We're glad our team could work alongside you to develop solutions and continue refining your process. Your comments on strategic guidance are equally valuable. We're committed to helping customers maximize the impact of their assessment programs, and feedback like yours helps us continue enhancing both our consulting approach and platform resources. We're encouraged that recent discussions around assessment strategy and video interviews have been beneficial, and we look forward to continuing our partnership with you!

HR Generalist  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "Strong Assessment Platform with Opportunities for Enhancement"

September 2, 2026

4.0

Pros

Criteria has been a valuable tool for improving our hiring process and helping us make more informed talent decisions. The platform is user-friendly, easy to navigate, and provides a wide range of assessments that help evaluate candidates beyond what a resume can show. One of the biggest advantages is the ability to identify candidates whose skills, cognitive abilities, and behavioral traits align with the requirements of the role. The reporting is clear and easy to understand, making it simple for hiring managers and HR teams to discuss results and compare applicants. Implementation was straightforward, and the customer support team has been responsive whenever assistance was needed. Overall, Criteria helps streamline recruitment, improve consistency in candidate evaluations, and supports more objective hiring decisions.

Cons

While Criteria offers many useful features, there are areas where the platform could be improved. Some assessments can feel lengthy from a candidate's perspective, which may impact completion rates for certain applicants. The customization options are helpful, but there is a learning curve when setting up assessment packages and interpreting more advanced reporting features. Additionally, some hiring managers may require extra training to fully understand how to use the assessment results effectively alongside interviews and other selection tools. Depending on the organization's size and hiring volume, the cost may be a consideration, particularly when budgets are tight. Although the platform provides valuable data, no assessment tool can replace human judgment, and organizations must ensure results are used as one component of a comprehensive hiring process.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 2, 2026

Hi Markarius, thank you for your thoughtful review. We're happy to hear that Criteria has helped improve your hiring process by providing a user-friendly experience, clear reporting, and valuable insights into candidates' skills, cognitive abilities, and behavioral traits. It's especially rewarding to know that our assessments are helping your team make more informed, consistent, and objective hiring decisions. We also appreciate your candid feedback around assessment length, customization, reporting complexity, and user training. These insights are incredibly valuable as we continue enhancing the platform and supporting customers in getting the most out of their assessment data. Thank you for partnering with us and for recognizing the important role assessments play alongside human judgment in building great teams.

Talent Acquisition Manager  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "Data-Driven Hiring Decisions"

September 2, 2026

5.0

Our overall experience with Criteria has been very positive. The assessments are thoughtfully designed but what really stands out is the support. Their team is responsive, accessible, and always willing to help when we need it.

Pros

We’ve been very impressed with the depth and quality of Criteria’s assessments. Incorporating these aptitude assessments into our hiring process has added real value by giving our managers an additional “talent signal” to consider when evaluating candidates. It helps us make more informed, data-driven hiring decisions.

Cons

With the variety of technical roles we hire for, building the right assessment batteries wasn’t always easy to do on our own. Thankfully, our Customer Success Manager, Othman, was always available when we had questions. He worked with his internal psych team to better understand our job descriptions and recommend assessments that made sense for some of our more niche positions.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 2, 2026

Hi Bryan, thanks for your thoughtful review! We're thrilled to hear that Criteria's assessments have added meaningful value to your hiring process by providing managers with an additional talent signal to support more informed, data-driven decisions. We're also especially pleased to hear your positive feedback about Othman (isn't he great?!) and our Customer Success team. Matching the right assessments to specialized and technical roles can be complex, and we're glad our team partnered with you so effectively to understand your unique hiring needs and recommend solutions tailored to those positions. Thank you for recognizing both the quality of our assessments and the support behind them. We appreciate your partnership and look forward to continuing to help your team make confident hiring decisions!

Analyst II - Talent Acquisition  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Efficient and User-Friendly Evaluation Journey"

September 3, 2026

5.0

Criteria Corp provides a smooth and reliable assessment experience for both recruiters and candidates. The platform is easy to administer, assessments are shared seamlessly, and the reporting is clear and actionable. It helps streamline the screening process while maintaining a positive candidate experience. The user interface is intuitive, and the insights generated support more informed hiring decisions.

Pros

The platform makes it simple to send assessments, track candidate progress, and review results through clear, actionable reports. It helps streamline the screening process while supporting data-driven hiring decisions and maintaining a positive candidate experience

Cons

While the platform is overall effective, there are opportunities to enhance reporting customization and make it easier to compare candidate results across assessments. Additional flexibility in candidate management workflows would further improve the recruiter experience.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 4, 2026

Hi Mayur, thank you for your thoughtful review. We're delighted to hear that Criteria has helped simplify your hiring process through easy assessment administration, clear reporting, and a positive candidate experience. It's especially rewarding to know that our insights are helping your team make more informed, data-driven hiring decisions. We also appreciate your feedback on reporting customization, candidate comparisons, and workflow flexibility. Thank you for being a valued partner and for sharing your experience with Criteria!

Recruiter  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "Good assessment platform"

September 2, 2026

4.0

My overall experience with Criteria has been good. It's reliable and usable. There are some things that could be enhanced but not many.

Pros

the thing I like most is how easy and reliable it is for candidates to use. I also appreciate the option to see candidate's individual answers for every one of my assessments.

Cons

I found the dashboard a little hard to navigate and I would also appreciate the option to be able to easily review and change questions in the assessment sent to candidate.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

September 2, 2026

Hi there, thanks for your review! We're glad you've found Criteria easy and reliable for candidates to use, and that access to individual candidate responses provides additional insight during the evaluation process. We also appreciate your feedback about dashboard navigation and assessment editing capabilities. Input like this helps us continue improving the platform and making it even easier for teams to manage their hiring workflows. We're pleased that your overall experience has been positive, and we look forward to continuing to support your hiring needs. Thank you for choosing Criteria!

HR Manager  
Used the software for: Less than 1 year

### "Assessments Made Easy for Onboarding New Hires "

December 11, 2024

5.0

Overall, we have had success with Criteria assessments in our hiring efforts, and we find that the interview tools included with the assessment results help bring alignment and consistency to our onboarding process.

Pros

Criteria not only provides research-backed content for a wide range of roles, but also allows you to create customized content tailored to the specific qualities you're seeking in a candidate.

Cons

I do wish there was an easier way to set a range for custom created content.

Switched from

[Wonderlic Select](https://www.capterra.com/p/145757/Wonderlic-Select/)

Cost and ease of use were our main reasons for seeking a new assessment company.

Review Source

Response from Criteria Corp

December 12, 2024

Hi Kat, thanks so much for taking the time to share your experience with Criteria. We're delighted that our research-backed content and assessment options have positively contributed to your hiring process. We appreciate your feedback regarding the customization range and as we are always looking for ways to enhance our platform's functionality. We will take your comments into consideration as we continue to improve our services. It's also great to know that our cost-effectiveness and user-friendly platform were key factors in your decision to switch to Criteria. We're committed to providing you with the best possible experience and support! Thank you for choosing Criteria.

## Send me user reviews about this product

### Fill out the form and we'll send a list of the top-rated software based on real user reviews directly to your inbox.

Talk to a Capterra advisor for free and get results within 15 minutes.