# ArcGIS Software Pricing, Alternatives & More 2026 | Capterra

> With the help of Capterra, learn about ArcGIS Software - reviews, pricing plans, popular comparisons to other GIS products and more.

Source: https://www.capterra.com/p/93333/ArcGIS

---

# 

 ArcGIS Software Review 2026: Features, Integrations, Pros & Cons

Last updated on March 13, 2026

Provider data verified by our Software Research team, and reviews moderated by our Reviews Verification team.

Independent research methodology

Capterra’s researchers use a mix of verified reviews, independent research and objective methodologies to bring you selection and ranking information you can trust. While we may earn a referral fee when you visit a provider through our links or speak to an advisor, this has no influence on our research or methodology. [Learn more](https://www.capterra.com/resources/proprietary-data-research/)

How Capterra verifies reviews

Capterra carefully verified over 2.5 million+ reviews to bring you authentic software experiences from real users. Our human moderators verify that reviewers are real people and that reviews are authentic. They use leading tech to analyze text quality and to detect plagiarism and generative AI. [Learn more](https://www.capterra.com/resources/how-we-verify-reviews/)

How Capterra ensures transparency

Capterra lists all providers across its website—not just those that pay us—so that users can make informed purchase decisions. Capterra is free for users. Software providers pay us for sponsored profiles to receive web traffic and sales opportunities. Sponsored profiles include a link-out icon that takes users to the provider’s website. [Learn more](https://www.capterra.com/resources/how-we-ensure-transparency/)

[Description](#description)[Use cases](#use-cases)[Alternatives](#alternatives)[Users](#users)[Pros and Cons](#pros-cons)[Features](#features)[Pricing](#pricing)[Integrations](#integrations)[Support](#support)[Reviews](#reviews)

ArcGIS

## What is ArcGIS?

Integrated collection of GIS software products; ArcGIS offers unique capabilities and flexible licensing for applying location-based analytics to your business practices. Gain greater insights using contextual tools to visualize and analyze your data. Collaborate and share via maps, apps, dashboards and reports.

## What is ArcGIS used for?

[GIS](https://www.capterra.com/gis-software/)[Route Planning](https://www.capterra.com/route-planning-software/)[Public Works](https://www.capterra.com/public-works-software/)

Top alternative

Featured

Overall rating

Based on 503 user reviews

Reviews sentiment

Positive

95%

Neutral

4%

Negative

1%

Pros & cons

Advanced spatial data processing

Widely adopted industry platform

Frequent crashes and glitches

High and complex licensing costs

Contact vendor  
for pricing

Free trial  
available

Capterra Shortlist charts the highest-rated and most popular products...

Our "Best of" badge program showcases products with the highest ratings...

Our "Best of" badge program showcases products with the highest ratings...

Do you work for ArcGIS?[Manage this product listing](https://digitalmarkets.gartner.com/get-listed/claim-bx?url=http://www.esri.com&name=ArcGIS)

## Compare with a popular alternative

Capterra selects software alternatives based on relevant features, verified user reviews and user interactions. Placement may be influenced by client status.

### ArcGIS

4.6 (503)

VS.

[4.6 (28)](https://www.capterra.com/p/79186/Cartegraph-Asset-Management/reviews/)

Starting Price

Contact vendor

Starting Price

Contact vendor

Free Trial

Free Version

Pricing Options

Free Trial

Free Version

Ease Of Use

3.9 (503)

Ease Of Use

4.3 (53)

Value For Money

4.0 (371)

Value For Money

4.3 (40)

Customer Service

4.1 (360)

Customer Service

4.7 (38)

## ArcGIS alternatives

[4.6 (1,420)](https://www.capterra.com/p/127994/Jobber/reviews/)

Starting price

$39.00

Per User, Per Month

Pricing Options

Free Trial

Free Version

User Rating

93%

of reviewers

rated it above 4 stars

[4.5 (384)](https://www.capterra.com/p/100468/eMaint-CMMS/reviews/)

Starting price

Contact vendor for pricing

Pricing Options

Free Trial

Free Version

User Rating

93%

of reviewers

rated it above 4 stars

Highest Rated

[PolicyMap](https://www.capterra.com/p/165945/PolicyMap/)

[4.8 (53)](https://www.capterra.com/p/165945/PolicyMap/reviews/)

Starting price

Contact vendor for pricing

Pricing Options

Free Trial

Free Version

User Rating

100%

of reviewers

rated it above 4 stars

[Learn More](https://www.capterra.com/p/165945/PolicyMap/)

[Trimble Cityworks](https://www.capterra.com/p/80839/CityWorks/)

[4.4 (27)](https://www.capterra.com/p/80839/CityWorks/reviews/)

Starting price

$1995.00

Per User, Per Month

Pricing Options

Free Trial

Free Version

User Rating

93%

of reviewers

rated it above 4 stars

[Learn More](https://www.capterra.com/p/80839/CityWorks/)

[View all alternatives](https://www.capterra.com/p/93333/ArcGIS/alternatives/)

## Who uses ArcGIS?

Based on Capterra reviews from the past 4 years

Talk to a software expert

to get a free software list  
tailored to your business needs

## Pros and Cons

Advanced spatial data processing

94% positive reviews out of 35

Most reviewers describe spatial analysis as highly flexible, enabling complex geographic studies and robust data visualization.

Frequent crashes and glitches

85% negative reviews out of 54

Most reviewers describe bugs and issues, including unexpected crashes, data loss, and confusing error messages during use.

Mohammad S

Project Engineer Electrical, 11 - 50 employees.

"The loading time is too much, even we are using computers with good spec some times we are stuck and have to restart it.."

Widely adopted industry platform

94% positive reviews out of 31

Most reviewers appreciate industry use, noting broad adoption, ongoing innovation, and support across many professional sectors.

Oumaima A

research analyst, 51 - 200 employees.

"It offers a robust and versatile platform that caters to the needs of various industries and sectors"

High and complex licensing costs

73% negative reviews out of 30

Most reviewers report licensing is expensive, restrictive, and complicated, limiting access for individuals and organizations.

Benjamin M

Civil Engineer, 10,001+ employees.

"Most tasks can be completed with a basic licence, but when additional licensing is required for a certain tool the software has to be restarted which leads to a 10 minute delay."

Comprehensive land and terrain analysis

95% positive reviews out of 22

Most reviewers indicate area and land analysis tools support diverse mapping, planning, and environmental projects efficiently.

Slow performance and heavy resource use

87% negative reviews out of 30

Most reviewers find performance and speed problematic, with slow loading, lag, and high hardware demands, especially on large projects.

## Features

Features with the highest number of reviews are displayed first. Those that have no reviews appear next, sorted alphabetically.

Data Import/Export

4.6 (75)

58.67% of 75 reviewers that rated this feature as important or highly important

With this capability, you can easily import and export data in formats like shapefiles, GeoJSON, KML, and CSV. Reviewers indicate ArcGIS supports diverse sources, offers simple workflows, and integrates with AutoCAD, Excel, and databases for flexible data sharing.

Data Mapping

4.6 (69)

59.42% of 69 reviewers that rated this feature as important or highly important

ArcGIS gives you powerful tools to visualize and analyze geographic data, supporting custom maps and multiple layers for infrastructure, environment, and demographics. Reviewers appreciate its intuitive interface, easy workflows, and compatibility with formats like .txt, .csv, and .xls.

Geographic Maps

4.7 (63)

58.73% of 63 reviewers that rated this feature as important or highly important

Visualize locations on a map

Location Tracking

4.2 (47)

34.04% of 47 reviewers that rated this feature as important or highly important

Identify the physical location of an individual, asset, device, etc.

Map Creation

4.7 (47)

59.57% of 47 reviewers that rated this feature as important or highly important

Create custom maps

Route Optimization

4.3 (47)

55.32% of 47 reviewers that rated this feature as important or highly important

Finding the most optimal routes for drivers based on various factors and constraints

ArcGIS 121 features

Representation of any object in 3D

Define levels of authorization for access to specific files or systems

Dashboard to view the status of ongoing processes, identify current incidents and track past activities

Track and document all activities across devices, networks, and other systems

One-off queries made on an as-needed basis

Generate one-off reports that meet information requirements

System alerts about the need to escalate an issue or request

Alerts or notifications of various types such as pop-up messages, sounds, banners, or badges

Application programming interface that allows for integration with other systems/databases

Manage assets throughout their lifecycle to optimize profit

Monitor the usage of assets, such as equipment, tools, software, etc., throughout their lifecycle

Identify and track items using barcode tags or RFID (radio-frequency identification) tags

Track and analyse user behavior within a system or network

Compare key metrics for the business against prominent players in the industry

AI-based platform which conducts a conversation via auditory or textual methods

Track the status of assets and whether they're checked in or out

Provides a channel for team members to share media files, communicate, and work together

A way to visually represent data where different categories of items are marked with different colors

Manage and track all internal and external communication conducted via calls, email, text, or chat

Process to track, record, and analyze expenses that occurred over the entire duration of a given project

Process of dividing customers into groups based on common characteristics

Add customized logos and colors to align with company branding

Customize data fields to support various needs and use cases

Customize contracts and forms to collect specific information

Alter the layout and content of reports

Pre-designed layouts that can be customized to match preferences and requirements

Assembly of graphs and charts for visualizing and tracking statistics/metrics

Creation and customization of dashboards

Import, collect, and capture data from multiple sources

Process of gathering, measuring, and analyzing accurate data

Connect to big data sources

Automatically retrieve and pull information from documents, websites, images, data sets, and other sources

With this capability, you can easily import and export data in formats like shapefiles, GeoJSON, KML, and CSV. Reviewers indicate ArcGIS supports diverse sources, offers simple workflows, and integrates with AutoCAD, Excel, and databases for flexible data sharing.

Ability to handle large datasets

ArcGIS gives you powerful tools to visualize and analyze geographic data, supporting custom maps and multiple layers for infrastructure, environment, and demographics. Reviewers appreciate its intuitive interface, easy workflows, and compatibility with formats like .txt, .csv, and .xls.

Synchronizing data between two or more devices/systems and automatically updating changes to maintain consistency

Translate EDI formats into data suitable for use with company applications.

Graphical representation of data

Supports common databases such as MySQL and Oracle

Artificial neural networks using multiple layers of processing are used to extract progressively higher level features from data.

Track and manage the decline in value of assets and plan for improvements

Manage sending personnel and resources to a site as needed

Plan when and how to dispose of outdated or decommissioned assets

Store, manage, and track all electronic documents in a centralized location

Store and organize documents in a centralized system

Assemble applications and processes by dragging over and arranging pre-built components

Track all personnel who operate company vehicles

Manage procedures that ensure organizational equipment remains in working condition

Monitor and maintain equipment used to manufacture and deploy products and services, and to reallocate assets where needed

Track the location of specific equipment at all times

Manage and track high-value assets including office equipment, furniture & more

Centralized database to track details of fixed assets such as depreciation and maintenance scheduling/history

Caters to sales teams

Form predictions based on past and present data/trends

Converting human-readable addresses into geographic coordinates

Virtual perimeter for a real-world geographic area

Visualize locations on a map

Determines the location of a device using GPS or an IP address

Geographic location of visitors determines behavior of the software

System to support the positioning, navigation, and timing (PNT) measurements of an object or individual

A visual display that uses a color spectrum to show how visitors interact with areas of a web page

Information, data and reports that are being tracked over time

Support for uploading and retaining image files in the cemetery records database

The ability of two or more systems to exchange information or data.

Track and monitor inventory items, such as raw materials, unfinished goods, and ready-to-sell items

Monitor the movement of one or more IT assets throughout the organization

Quantifiable metrics to track objectives, gauge milestones, and evaluate the success of a particular activity

Identify the physical location of an individual, asset, device, etc.

Manage, maintain and track the performance of assets and equipment

Schedule predetermined or ad hoc maintenance services and labor requests

Create custom maps

Share maps with internal and external stakeholders

Collect and maintain structured information that describes data or content

Log miles driven for tax deduction or reimbursement purposes

Access software remotely via mobile devices

Access the system via a mobile application

Observe and track the demand, usage, progress or quality of a system, product, or user

Manage and support multiple languages

Manage and support multiple locations

Allows users to manage data from a number of sources

Manage and track customer orders for goods, investments, or any other purchases

A set of indicators that tracks the performance of networks, applications, systems, teams, etc.

Predict future data based on historical data sets

Analyzing historical and current data and generating a model to help predict future outcomes.

Minimizes equipment failures and optimizes asset reliability through scheduled inspections, repairs, and replacements

Streamlining repetitive tasks and activities through automated and predefined workflows

Evaluate the degree to which business operations bring monetary gains

Share pre-configured sets of data organized and presented in a specific manner with the organization

Analyze and gain insights into data in real-time

Receive data and information in real time

Active monitoring of systems, applications, or networks

Notifications that are delivered to users as soon as an event occurs

Active reporting of data and metrics

Timed notification for any upcoming task, deadline, appointment, or activity

Collection, analysis, and representation of numerical data and generation of reports to understand various patterns

View and track pertinent metrics to find patterns and gain insights from data

Manage the entire lifecycle of a reservation, from the initial booking to the actual service or event

Set & manage permission levels based on user roles and restrict access to only authorized individuals

Finding the most optimal routes for drivers based on various factors and constraints

Plan daily routes to optimize employee scheduling and provide directions

Plan availability and assign specific time slots for tasks and resources

Visual representation of performance data, enabling users to monitor progress, identify trends, and make data-driven decisions

Search and filter data across systems to locate required information by entering keywords or certain criteria

Access, combine, transform, and store data without the help of an IT department

Assign, track and manage customers' service requests such as service enquiry, feedback/complaints and more

Allow users to access multiple services after entering their login credentials once

A study of entities based on topological, geographic and geometric attributes.

Apply statistical/mathematical models to sets of data

Track the status over time for a request, process, asset, or transaction

At a high level, visualize a preferred outcome, define goals and identify specific steps to achieve them

Attach digital tags to documents and assets for identification, search, or monitoring purposes

Create, manage and track all task activities and progression

Track and manage the scheduling of tasks

Set up connections to third-party platforms to improve business processes

Review data from past periods to reveal recurring tendencies and predict future performance

Visually identify direction of development and areas that require attention

Manage user accounts, profiles, roles, permissions, and other details across applications, devices or networks

Interact with data visualization elements, such as charts and graphs, to drill down into data

An extended application or connector that enables users to perform additional services with their current set of tools

Creating, assign, and track jobs and/or tasks for work orders

Create, design and manage workflows for repetitive tasks

Get Advice

We can help you find the software with the features you need.

Features

4.6 (500)

4.6

Based on 500 reviews

## Pricing

Value for money

4.0 (371)

### Starting price

Contact vendor  
for pricing

Free trial  
available

[View all Pricing Plans](https://www.capterra.com/p/93333/ArcGIS/pricing/)

Value for money

4.0 (371)

4.0

Based on 371 reviews

## Integrations

[

AutoCAD](https://www.capterra.com/p/265024/AutoCAD/)

Connect with a Capterra advisor for a free 15-minute consultation

Get a personalized software list aligned to your business needs with guidance from our expert advisors. Our team has helped 1 million+ businesses like yours find options that fit their needs.

## Support, customer service and training options

Customer Service

4.1 (360)

Support

-   Email/Help Desk
-   FAQs/Forum
-   Knowledge Base
-   Phone Support
-   24/7 (Live rep)
-   Chat

Training

-   In Person
-   Live Online
-   Webinars
-   Documentation
-   Videos

Deployment

-   Web
-   Android
-   iPhone/iPad

Typical users

-   Freelancers
-   Small businesses
-   Mid size businesses
-   Enterprises

Customer Service

4.1 (360)

4.1

Based on 360 reviews

## User reviews

Overall rating

4.6

Based on 503 reviews

Filter by rating

5(320)

4(158)

3(19)

2(3)

1(3)

Mentioned topic

Sorted by most recent

RH

Rod H.

Civil Engineer III

Civil Engineering

### "ArcGIS Software review"

5.0

Overall Rating

5.0

5.0

Ease of Use

4.0

4.0

Features

5.0

5.0

Customer Service

5.0

5.0

Likelihood to Recommend

3/10

March 13, 2026

Integrated well with local government GIS. We found the software to easily learn if you have training in other CAD software.

Pros

The ability to quickly develop utility maps from GIS. This software works great for realtime updating of maps on an electronic notebook out in the field.

Cons

It is a Esti software product so it will be overly expensive but you are buying the industry best GIS software

Review source

Incentivized review: software users are invited to submit an honest review and offered a nominal incentive for their time and effort. All incentivized reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

TK

Tim K.

Draftsman

Utilities

### "ArcGIS is a quality product"

4.0

Overall Rating

4.0

4.0

Ease of Use

3.0

3.0

Features

5.0

5.0

Customer Service

5.0

5.0

Likelihood to Recommend

7/10

November 20, 2025

Overall my experience is positive. I use it on a daily basis, it has tools that help us accurately represent our system.

Pros

The ability to use data across multiple platforms. The ease of importing data into other platforms we use.

Cons

Sometimes the software feels clunky. It does feel like it was designed by data analysists, not people who'd actually utilize it,

Review source

Incentivized review: software users are invited to submit an honest review and offered a nominal incentive for their time and effort. All incentivized reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

AP

Anthony P.

GIS Supervisor

Utilities

### "Maps are now interactive"

3.0

Overall Rating

3.0

3.0

Ease of Use

4.0

4.0

Features

4.0

4.0

Customer Service

5.0

5.0

Likelihood to Recommend

7/10

November 5, 2025

I've used ArcGIS since 2002 and have seen the system embrace web-based mapping as opposed to a workflow that solely supported paper based or PDF based static maps

Pros

The ArcGIS eco-system has come a long way and now incorporates mobile workflows and data entry to enable an enterprise-wide solution

Cons

Oftentimes, small bugs and issues can set back operations, but once these are worked out, all functions resume normally.

Switched from

[MapInfo Pro](https://www.capterra.com/p/10009553/MapInfo-Pro/)

More interactivity and web-based editing workflows

Review source

Non-incentivized review: any software user can leave a review for any product listed on our site. All submitted reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

BM

Benjamin M.

Civil Engineer

Utilities

### "Field Leader for Geosptial Analysis"

5.0

Overall Rating

5.0

5.0

Ease of Use

5.0

5.0

Features

5.0

5.0

Customer Service

4.0

4.0

Likelihood to Recommend

10/10

July 29, 2025

Pros

Large amount of online documentation to assist users in completing their geospatial analysis. Bugs are well documented and work-arounds are available.

Cons

The licensing levels are frustrating. Most tasks can be completed with a basic licence, but when additional licensing is required for a certain tool the software has to be restarted which leads to a 10 minute delay. Working daily with an advanced licence is triple the cost.

Review source

Incentivized review: software users are invited to submit an honest review and offered a nominal incentive for their time and effort. All incentivized reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

BP

Boston P.

Broadband

Internet

### "Broadband Tech"

4.0

Overall Rating

4.0

4.0

Ease of Use

5.0

5.0

Features

4.0

4.0

Customer Service

5.0

5.0

Likelihood to Recommend

9/10

July 17, 2025

Pros

The easy of use in the field is a game changer. Without it it would be a nightmare to manage if facilities.

Cons

The lack of a offline mode makes it difficult in areas where we have facilities. Also some of the add in county functions struggle to load.

Review source

Non-incentivized review: any software user can leave a review for any product listed on our site. All submitted reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

KS

Kevin S.

Operations

Utilities

### "ArcGIS is the industry standard for GIS Software"

5.0

Overall Rating

5.0

5.0

Ease of Use

3.0

3.0

Features

5.0

5.0

Customer Service

5.0

5.0

Likelihood to Recommend

10/10

June 30, 2025

We have been using ArcGIS for about 6 years to map water and sewer infrastructure. We started our ArcGIS organization from the ground up. It really has been a learning process for us and we are constantly discovering new ways to use ArcGIS to collect and present data.

Pros

ArcGIS is a valuable software that is essential to our operations. We use it to develop maps and then these maps are integrated into other software applications through the API or as standalone web applications. ArcGIS really is the industry standard.

Cons

We have to have someone on staff that is dedicated to running and maintaining our ArcGIS organization. There is absolutely a learning curve.

Review source

Non-incentivized review: any software user can leave a review for any product listed on our site. All submitted reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

DH

Daniel H.

Power Platform Developer

Information Technology and Services

### "Strong GIS Tool with a bit of a learning curve"

4.0

Overall Rating

4.0

4.0

Ease of Use

4.0

4.0

Features

5.0

5.0

Customer Service

3.0

3.0

Likelihood to Recommend

8/10

June 3, 2025

My overall experience with ArcGIS has been positive, especially for advanced GIS tasks, though it requires patience to master.

Pros

ArcGIS offers a highly intuitive interface, robust mapping features, and excellent data visualization tools for professionals.

Cons

Depending on how the data is structured and how you envision your visualization to look there can at times be a steep learning curve making it challenging for beginners

Switched from

[Microsoft Power BI](https://www.capterra.com/p/176586/Power-BI/)

Bing maps is now being deprecated and is at end of it's life

Review source

Non-incentivized review: any software user can leave a review for any product listed on our site. All submitted reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

AO

Alanna O.

Systems Analyst Trainee

Information Technology and Services

### "ArcGIS Reveiw"

5.0

Overall Rating

5.0

5.0

Ease of Use

4.0

4.0

Features

5.0

5.0

Customer Service

5.0

5.0

Likelihood to Recommend

9/10

May 27, 2025

What stands out is the capability of handling everything from basic mapping to advanced spatial statistics. It offers excellent visualization for map creation and seamless integration.

Pros

ArcGIS has proven to be a powerful spatial analysis tool. The analysis tools make it easy to perform complex tasks and allows detailed / high quality visualization for mapping.

Cons

ArcGis is definitely on the more expensive side but given we are a large corporation the fees aren't too bad. There is also a bit of a steep learning curve. It takes some time to get used to.

Review source

Incentivized review: software users are invited to submit an honest review and offered a nominal incentive for their time and effort. All incentivized reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

AB

Anne B.

Cartographer

Government Administration

### "ArcGIS is excellent software"

5.0

Overall Rating

5.0

5.0

Ease of Use

4.0

4.0

Features

5.0

5.0

Customer Service

4.0

4.0

Likelihood to Recommend

10/10

March 30, 2025

Pros

Broad capabilities and a multitude of integrations with other software

Cons

Unexpected errors that shut down the whole program, and some of the interfaces are not intuitive

Review source

Non-incentivized review: any software user can leave a review for any product listed on our site. All submitted reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

AA

Ana A.

Estagiário de Investigação

Education Management

### "Comprehensive and Reliable GIS Solution"

5.0

Overall Rating

5.0

5.0

Ease of Use

5.0

5.0

Features

5.0

5.0

Customer Service

4.0

4.0

Likelihood to Recommend

10/10

February 21, 2025

Overall, it’s a robust tool for mapping and data analysis.

Pros

ArcGIS is a strong tool to visualizing and analize spatial information

Cons

The software can be quite expensive for small teams.

Review source

Non-incentivized review: any software user can leave a review for any product listed on our site. All submitted reviews are subject to our verification process prior to publication.

[View all Reviews](https://www.capterra.com/p/93333/ArcGIS/reviews/)

Popular comparisons

[PolicyMap vs ArcGIS](https://www.capterra.com/compare/93333-165945/ArcGIS-vs-PolicyMap)[Maptitude vs ArcGIS](https://www.capterra.com/compare/93333-93335/ArcGIS-vs-Maptitude)

[Asset Essentials vs ArcGIS](https://www.capterra.com/compare/93333-113574/ArcGIS-vs-AssetEssentials) 

Independent research methodology

Capterra's researchers use a mix of verified reviews, independent research and objective methodologies to bring you selection and ranking information you can trust. While we may earn a referral fee when you visit a provider through our links or speak to an advisor, this has no influence on our research or methodology.

[Learn more](https://www.capterra.com/resources/proprietary-data-research/)

How Capterra verifies reviews

Capterra carefully verified over 2.5 million+ reviews to bring you authentic software experiences from real users. Our human moderators verify that reviewers are real people and that reviews are authentic. They use leading tech to analyze text quality and to detect plagiarism and generative AI.

[Learn more](https://www.capterra.com/resources/how-we-verify-reviews/)

How Capterra ensures transparency

Capterra lists all providers across its website—not just those that pay us—so that users can make informed purchase decisions. Capterra is free for users. Software providers pay us for sponsored profiles to receive web traffic and sales opportunities. Sponsored profiles include a link-out icon that takes users to the provider's website.

[Learn more](https://www.capterra.com/resources/how-we-ensure-transparency/)