---
title: "Greenshades Reviews 2026. Verified Reviews, Pros & Cons | Capterra"
description: "Is Greenshades the right Human Resources solution for you? Explore 27 verified user reviews from people in industries like yours to make a confident choice."
source_url: "https://www.capterra.com/p/148355/Benefits-Solution/reviews/"
page_type: "reviews"
language: "en"
publication_date: "2026-11-20"
---

Greenshades

4.4 (27)

[View alternatives](https://www.capterra.com/p/148355/Benefits-Solution/alternatives/)

Provider data verified by our Software Research team, and reviews moderated by our Reviews Verification team. [Learn more](https://www.capterra.com/our-story/)

* * *

Last updated November 20th, 2026

# Reviews of Greenshades

Ease of use

4.4

Customer Service

4.4

## Pros and Cons in Reviews

GS

Gary S

Director of AdministrationReligious Institutions, 51 - 200 employeesUsed the software for: More than 2 years.

“The system is customizable and the support team is accessible and eager to help. Though the system was originally built for MS Dynamics GP, Greenshades has also customized the system to work in a variety of ways with SL. “

May 19, 2021

RR

Ruth R

Human Resources DirectorHigher Education, 201 - 500 employeesUsed the software for: More than 2 years.

“For the price, it is easy to use and I like that the information entered in the Greenshades software carries over to our payroll system entry for entry instead of a general "dump" of information on the accounting side.“

June 29, 2021

AI

AZI I

VP FinanceRetail, 1,001 - 5,000 employeesUsed the software for: More than 2 years.

“The technical supports are great and reachable.“

July 12, 2021

## Showing most helpful reviews

Showing 1-25 of 27 available reviews

Sort by:

Most Helpful

Rating

Company Size

Reviewer's Role

Length of Use

Frequency of Use

AW

Amanda W.  
HR Assistant  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Great Software"

October 30, 2026

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

That the initial integration was very easy. Great support and training on how to use it. The software is very easy to use for Payroll & HR. The onboarding and benefits are wonderful.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

They don't have a Time Clock that offers what we need. We use schedules in our offices and that is not something they can accommodate.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

Fantastic Payroll, Onboarding & Benefits. Wish they would improve the Time Clock. Looking forward to any updates they make in the future.

Review Source

GB

GLEN B.  
CFO  
Used the software for: Less than 1 year

### "\[sensitive content hidden\] IS AWESOME"

February 23, 2026

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

INTERFACES WITH GS HR EASE OF MAKING CHANGES ONCE A PAYROLL HAS STARTED AS FAR AS CHANGING HOURS WORKED OR CHANGING DEDUCTIONS.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

THE SETUP WAS VERY CONFUSING AND ALOT OF TIME WAS INVOLVED. I HAD A DIFFICULT TIME UNDERSTANDING THE G/L MAPPING.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

VERY FRUSTRATED FOR AWHILE AND NOW THINGS SEEM TO BE CLICKING. 4TH QTR WAS PRETTY BRUTAL. I AM ANXIOUS TO SEE WHAT THE FIRST QUARTER BRINGS FOR PAYROLL QUARTERLIES

Switched from

[One Step GPS](https://www.capterra.com/p/197399/One-Step-GPS/)

MICROSOFT GP WILL NOT SUPPORT THE PAYROLL TAX TABLES OR UPDATE SS/40K/HSA MAX AMOUNTS AT THE END OF 2026 OR 2027. WE WOULD HAVE BEEN SOL.

Review Source

RB

ROCKY B.  
CFO  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Greenshades - A Payroll Solution custom fit for all industries"

January 21, 2026

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

Interfaces with ERP payroll module so less time is spent processing payroll 1,400 employees in multiple related companies. Greenshades provides secure access for all emplyees to receive payroll hstory and year end documents through the portal without consuming extra administrative staff's time.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

Time to implement the services customized to our company needs. Necessity to provide historical information that was not readily available.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

Greenshades provides the sofisticated services in a proficient manner that allows us to focus on company profitability instead of task oriented internal processes.

Alternatives considered

[Paycom](https://www.capterra.com/p/130949/Paycom/)

Reasons for choosing Greenshades

Affordability and limited functionality to meed our basic needs.

Review Source

CNO  
Used the software for: Less than 1 year

### "Payroll"

December 14, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

The ability to access your payroll information from anywhere and to look back at months prior is amazing.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

Some staff struggle with using apps and accessing email. It is a change process that can't be overlooked during implementation.

Review Source

HH

Haley H.  
Client Services Manager  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Mid-Size Payroll Service using for Tax Purposes"

May 19, 2021

3.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

The software is quite easily to use and information can be manipulated.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

The software does not communicate well with our payroll software (Darwin 16). It doesn't pull the correct information and since the techs with Greenshades don't know much about Darwin they state they can't fix it. Also we are using the software in Alabama mostly and the software is not even capable of creating an upload file with our state.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

We have over 7000 W-2's that we process, so it is good to have as an information gather. However, we must go over the information closely, for it is incorrect in some ways.

Reasons for choosing Greenshades

He has been with Darwin since 2000. We have looked into other software in the last two years, both payroll and tax related. We have not decided if we are ready to move.

Review Source

TD

Tammy D.  
HR Manager  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Greenshades & Image Pointe/Dignity Apparel "

June 19, 2025

4.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

Mostly very user friendly. Love the support that is available and the options of remote support if great.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

Sometimes not being able to quickly get to a report for lack of not knowing how. Every once in a while, a support ticket can take a long time to get solved.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

We have been using it for quite some time. We went from paper record keeping to Greenshades so I have no comparison.

Review Source

Response from Greenshades Software

June 20, 2025

Hi Tammy, Thank you for your thoughtful review and for being a loyal Greenshades user. We're so glad to hear that you've had a positive experience with our support team and find the platform user-friendly. We've noted your feedback around reporting and support response times and are sharing it with our teams to help drive ongoing improvements. We appreciate your continued partnership!

AM

Angela M.  
Payroll Accountant  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Great customer service"

June 25, 2025

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

I like the Greenshades most is their impressive customer service. The representatives are very professional and patient.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

The least about Greenshades is the product price. It's increasing every year. It's hard for the small business to afford.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

The overall experience with Greenshades is positive and great. The only hope is to make product more affordable for small business.

Review Source

Response from Greenshades Software

June 26, 2025

Angela, Thank you for your feedback and for being a loyal Greenshades user! We're glad to hear you've had a positive experience with our team—providing excellent service is a top priority! We understand pricing is a concern for small businesses and appreciate you sharing your perspective. Your input helps us continue to improve.

RR

Ruth R.  
Human Resources Director  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Great product"

June 30, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

This software is much less expensive than any other product I have reviewed. For the price, it is easy to use and I like that the information entered in the Greenshades software carries over to our payroll system entry for entry instead of a general "dump" of information on the accounting side.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

When calling into customer service, it is difficult to work my way up to an "expert" who can fix an issue that takes more knowledge than the front line person has. It would be nice to have a dedicated customer service person that I could talk to each time I have an issue instead of calling in and a random person helping me. When this happens I have to explain each time how our benefits are set up. If I had a dedicated person that I could call who only dealt with a specific number of companies, they would more easily and quickly understand the issue I am having instead of me spending 10 minutes or more explaining what I need.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

It has been good.

Reasons for choosing Greenshades

The cost was a major factor. Also, the way entries in Greenshades carry over to our payroll system.

Review Source

aI

azi I.  
VP Finance  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Payroll Reporting"

July 14, 2021

4.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

Since we started using the software, we don't have to issue check stubs to employee anymore. Our year end distribution of W2 to employees and the reporting process to authorities were smooth and finished on timely manner.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

the widow for submission of W2 with a staggering increase in price - this need to be modified to lesser increase in cost or longer period. instead of having 5 different pricing level, reduce it to 3 maybe with a slightly longer window.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

The technical supports are great and reachable. Most of the problems are solved within reasonable time.

Reasons for choosing Greenshades

we were suggested by great plain software technical support to use Greenshades and that was a great decision we've made.

Review Source

GC

Gina C.  
HR/Finance Manager  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Basic Greenshades use"

July 9, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

The software is super easy to use. I only use the basic time keeping module and W-2 printing/reporting. Anytime I call support they are helpful and always follow up with me if they don't have answers.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

Greenshades was very difficult to deploy in 2013. I felt like the company grew so fast it couldn't keep up. IT seemd when the company moved to the cloud, there was a few bumps. We are a 24/7 operation so the down time for upgrades or maintenance cause our team some issues.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

Working with this company overall has been a positive experience. I would recommend the software to small companies however I haven't used a lot of the other products.

Review Source

JK

Jennifer K.  
Controller  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Greenshades Review"

May 10, 2023

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

We were completely paper based before we went live with Greenshades and now are 100% electronic thanks to their software.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

When there is an issue it usually takes the support team several weeks or months to address.

Review Source

GS

Gary S.  
Director of Administration  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "A Helpful and Welcome Tool"

May 20, 2021

4.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

We are using Greenshades along with our Microsoft Dynamics SL accounting package to provide online access for employees to their paystubs and W2's among other uses (we process an in-house payroll). The system is customizable and the support team is accessible and eager to help. Though the system was originally built for MS Dynamics GP, Greenshades has also customized the system to work in a variety of ways with SL. For what the software provides, it is a good value!

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

Since the software is not made primarily for Dynamics SL, at times it can be frustrating to make things work perfectly. However, although the support team is very helpful, there are some limitations that may not satisfy all users. Overall all though, the pros outweigh the cons!

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

We have really enjoyed working with Greenshades. In fact, they are one of our best and most responsive corporate partners and business developers. They are professional and always responsive and available to help.

Reasons for choosing Greenshades

The other products were prohibitively expensive and Greenshades was a good value for what our priorities and needs were.

Review Source

MJ

Maria J.  
Accounts Payable Manager  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "1099 Submission"

June 30, 2021

4.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

It is convenient for filing 1099 for contract workers without having to do paperwork.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

The portal / website is a bit confusing because the steps are not very clear when revisiting the website. I didn't know that some steps did not need updating before completing submission.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

Greenshades is a very convenient tool in submitting 1099s to the IRS. Technical support returns my emails / calls whenever I need assistance with a short wait period.

Review Source

JW

Jolene W.  
Accounting Manager  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "May2021 Greenshades"

May 19, 2021

4.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

Timesheets have been a success for our administrative staff and are easy to use and import into Dynamics GP. The payroll tax module has been a great tool for reviewing and filing our quarterly and annual taxes. Integration of the software was simple. Love that customer service is part of the package.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

Hoping for a smoother transition to add online W2's for our employees as we looked into this last year and seemed like a lot of work so we did not add this option. Also to allow our employee's to see more than just one or two years of W2's without needing to purchase an extra plan.

Review Source

MH

Maci H.  
Human Resources Manager  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "Greenshades in the 21st Century"

June 9, 2022

4.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

All of my employees utilize this software and enjoy the function of all their tax and pay information in one easy stored location

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

My biggest con is that the site operates VERY slowly sometimes. I feel like I am working in 2003 again with how slow the program is. This is not an issue with my computer or connectivity. Greenshades is the only site that does this.

Review Source

SR

Sheila R.  
Payroll Tax Manager  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Greenshades Software Review"

May 19, 2021

4.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

I like the year end feature for the ease of use. The tax software is also good and very easy to use. Payroll Inspector is very nice in that it will determine the correct local taxes for employees.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

I feel that the reporting is lacking and I would like more ability to modify and customize reports that are not available in our payroll system, but could be built as adhoc reports in Greenshades.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

The main issues I have had with Greenshades is sometimes the payroll inspector will make suggestions that are incorrect. I have to send over the rulings to Greenshades to get them to update the data.

Review Source

SB

Sandra B.  
HR Manager  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Keeps me on track"

July 14, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

Greenshades is very easy to use to submit quarterly and annual tax returns, and I really appreciate the daily reminder emails within the week that the tax returns are due. I also appreciate being able to complete the Federal I-9 forms online with Greenshades.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

I wish that it supported a few more of the local taxes/fees that we encounter in certain states. Even though the returns for these are fairly simple for the few employees we have in the affected states, it would be nice to be able to process them like we do the other taxes.

Reasons for choosing Greenshades

It integrated well with our accounting system and was recommended by our consultant.

Review Source

JC

John C.  
Financial Systems Analyst  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Simply a Great Product"

July 9, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

While we don't use all of the Greenshades modules that are available, we rely on it for our 1099 reporting and IRS filing. It is simply an easy to use, life saver around tax time. We've have never had a problem installing it, using it, and have come to rely on it for our filings. Their support staff is very responsive and instructive .I would hate to think what our filings would be like without it!

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

I can't think of any: we've been using the product for several years now and have never had a problem with it. It is the one third-party software package that I worry about the least.

Review Source

LF

Lisa F.  
Accounts Payable Manager  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "1099 PROCESS NEVER BEEN EASIER "

July 15, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

The software gives a peace of mind. It is very user friendly, and it simplifies the entire 1099 process at year end. You drop your company vendor information on a Template and upload to their site. After uploading your company’s vendor information, Greenshades Software reviews your vendor information, and they flag any potential error or errors so you're able to correct before you hit the button to send to IRS. Not only that, but they will also mail and transmit 1099 file to IRS for you. Can you say stress free?

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

Hmmm, sorry, I cannot think of anything now .

Reasons for choosing Greenshades

Greenshades was more of a time saver. It eliminated the manual work from an already stressful time of year.

Review Source

JM

Joe M.  
Corporate Accountant  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Good Products"

May 19, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

The original price was attractive and the ease of use.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

The original set up was a challenge to finalize.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

We have been using Greenshades for a long time and the ease of use along with additional functions have been great.

Reasons for choosing Greenshades

The price was a significant factor.

Review Source

LD

Lorrie D.  
Payroll  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Greenshades review"

May 19, 2021

4.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

Easy to use, customer service is prompt, patient and knowledgeable.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

Some of the reports could be more user friendly and customizable.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

Tax reporting/filing is easier with Greenshades, our employees enjoy being able to view their check and print them themselves.

Review Source

SE

Sheila E.  
Staff Accountant  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "Greenshades Review for 2020"

May 25, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

I always thought it was very user friendly and contained pertinent information that every employee would find helpful. I especially liked having our PTO balances on the paystub.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

It seemed to hard to set up for some employees but once it was set up it was very easy to use.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

I always enjoyed the ease of use and when I had to contact Greenshades for assistance, they were always very knowledgeable and friendly and followed up after the initial contact.

Review Source

MH

Mary H.  
Controller  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "1099 User"

May 19, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

1099 distribution to vendors and upload to IRS

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

Could not upload 1099 NEC to IRS using Greenshades

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

Before 1099 NEC form, I would have highly recommended Greenshades but would like to see 1099 NEC also be able to upload to IRS

Switched from

Switched Accounting systems and American Healthtech was no longer an option for processing 1099's

Review Source

Lisa H.  
Payroll Coordinator  
Used the software for: 3-5 years

### "GS Review"

May 19, 2021

5.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

The ease of maneuvering in and out of the tabs and screens

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

On the Political Subdivision under the employee tab, the drop down is very large. Wish we could type in a few letters that narrows the search down instead of having to scroll.

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

It has definitely gotten better over the years. Very happy with everything now!!

Reasons for choosing Greenshades

GS offered the PA New Hire reporting and the Political Subdivision for local taxes in PA.

Review Source

CE

Carol E.  
Payroll Manager  
Used the software for: 1-3 years

### "Greenshade User"

May 18, 2021

2.0

What do you like best about Greenshades?

It was ok system. The webpage is easy to get around on.

What do you dislike about Greenshades?

This package is very lacking compared to others. Customer service is non-existent

What problem is Greenshades solving and how is that benefiting you?

Poor. Very limited. We had to move to a more complex system

Switched from

Great Planes is an accounting package, we need something that took care of all the HR and payroll issues

Review Source

Similar Products

Featured

## Send me user reviews about this product

### Fill out the form and we'll send a list of the top-rated software based on real user reviews directly to your inbox.